Copyright offoffonline, 2004

Momma, Make it Stop
by Nicholas Seeley
The Italian American Reconciliation reviewed April 29
There oughta be a law against theatre-as-advertising.

Now, there's nothing wrong with acting showcases. They're a way for performers to demonstrate their talents to directors and agents, and, like TV commercials or the plastic-wrapped section in the Sunday paper, they're fine as long as they're clearly labeled, and no one asks you to pay (much) for them.

But going to a piece of theater and finding a showcase is like renting Evita on DVD, and getting a disc full of old Infiniti commercials.

And that's the story of Italian-American Reconciliation at Theatre 3. It's a production devoid of any attempt to take risks or go beyond the stage directions to find the truth of a scene -- and to top it off, the actors who are using this vehicle to advertise themselves just aren't doing a very good job.

Most of the cast look as if they've taken their acting lessons from Paulie Walnuts, and the stage is full of tight shirts, wretched dialects, and macho poses. These caricatures not only obliterate the subtlety of Shanley's dialogue, they say something ugly about the mentality of the producers. Can these folks really think of nothing that defines Italian-Americans other than bad accents and cheap suits? Maybe they should choose another topic.

Seth Capozza does have some charming moments as Aldo, the neurotic, pseudo-brechtian narrator, but he doesn't have the inner life necessary to fill out Aldo’s extensive monologues.

Audience members with the willpower not to leave at intermission will be treated to the play’s only small saving grace, in the form of Alex Dawson, as Janice, the brutal femme-fatale that Aldo has to confront. Dawson is laboring under the same silly dialect and overly-demonstrative blocking as everyone else, but she somehow finds a germ of truth that permits us to believe an actual human being could talk and act as her character does.

Her scene with Aldo is also the best writing in the play, With a little help from the text, (and from Dawson) Capozza actually manages to keep acting when he’s not talking. But it’s all downhill again once Janice leaves stage.

Part of the problem with this show is the choice of material. The play is a collection fragmented scenes in which men complain about women, mostly to themselves or to the audience. Not Shanley’s finest hour, but not irredeemable. However, when performed amateurishly, the talky, abstruse and wildly metaphorical writing quickly becomes so much hot air.

The scent of high school cafeteria theater permeates the production values: the costumes look to be the actors’ own clothes, the set pieces are discordant, and, excepting one pretty backdrop painting, could have been pulled from any theatre-shop basement. Every scene has three generic-looking props that the actors re-arrange, but never use.

The program, tellingly, says nothing about the director's vision, the company’s goals, or even the play itself – it contains only the actor’s bios. This show isn’t theatre, it’s a marketing event, and it has all the mystery and charm of a blue light special at K-mart.
THE ITALIAN AMERICAN RECONCILIATION

Theater 3 (Director's Company)
Category:  Comedy
Written by: 
Directed by: 
Produced by:  RightNow productions/ Seth Capozza
Opens:  April 28
Closes:  May 2
Running Time:  2 hours 20 mins

Address:  153 Mercer Street
New York, NY 10036
Mapquest Directions

Click for  Theater Listing
Show's Website
BOX OFFICE
Tickets:  $15.00
$12 - Student
Phone: 
Hours: 
Online Ticketing: None
CREDITS
Creative Team
Written by:  John Patrick Shanley
Directed by:  Jamie Wollrab
Produced by:  Rightnow Productions
Light Designer:  Matt Fick
Sound Designer:  Jamie Wollrab
Set Designer:  Evan Lewis
Costume Designer:  Sarah Maiorino

Cast
Seth Capozza as Aldo Scalicki
Scott Wallack as Huey Maximilian Bonfigliano
Rachel Becker as Teresa
Margaret Lepara as Aunt May
Alex Dawson as Janice